Volume 4 Issue 15 - August 01, 2006
M.S.J.E.’s Proposed Amendments to the Disability Act – a façade for Inclusion, Justice & Empowerment
Amendments to Persons with Disabilities Act, 1995 have been long awaited now. The shortcomings of the Act were glaringly visible even before it came into force upon its notification on 7 February 1996, says Meenu Bhambhani.
An Amendment Committee, headed by Dr. Amita Dhanda, was appointed by the Government within three years of the notification of the Act. The Committee comprised of experts in the field of disability and senior leaders of disability sector like S.K. Rungta, Merry Barua, J.P. Gadkari, Aloka Guha, R. Ramachandran, Dr. D.K. Menon and Surrender Saini. This Committee submitted its report in 1999 itself and since then it has been gathering dust in the shelves of the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment (M.S.J.E.)
Having suddenly woken up from its
slumber, M.S.J.E. has shown scant respect for the recommendations of this
Committee and proposed its own set of amendments to the Disability Act. A
large number of recommendations of the Amita Dhandha Committee still hold valid and had M.S.J.E. even bothered
to accept those recommendations not only would that have given dignity to
the Office of Chief Commissioner for Persons with Disabilities but would also
have given recognition to the civil and political rights of disabled people
M.S.J.E. has made a mockery of transparency and participation of stakeholders in the process of facilitating change and empowerment for disabled people. Instead of having state/regional level consultative workshops to invite suggestions from key stakeholders, M.S.J.E. once again, in a clandestine manner, put up its own set of proposed amendments on the website even before its own deadline of 31 July 2006! Mercifully, as a result of the pressure built by the disability sector, the deadline, as of today, has been extended by six months, that is up to 30 November 2006.
If one looks at some of these proposed amendments one would notice that they have failed to address the issues that have been the root cause of this Act remaining ineffective. One of the major criticisms of this Act has been that it lacks teeth and the definition of disability is very narrow since it leaves out several key categories out of its purview. The proposed amendments have failed to address even the most basic of its criticisms. While the definition of disability in the proposed amendments is a change from impairment based definition to the one that screens disability on the basis of activity limitation (used in developed countries). However, the categories continue to remain seven as they are in the Act at present. Amita Dhandha Committee had proposed inclusion of six other categories including Autism, Cerebral Palsy, Hemophilia, Multiple Disability, Thalassemia and Speech Impairment. Further it also recommended that for “purposes of the chapter on education, disability also includes specific learning disability”. Inclusion of Hemophilia and Thalassemia has been a long pending demand of the disability sector. And in fact disabling diseases like H.I.V. and A.I.D.S. should also have been included in the ambit of disability in the proposed amendments. But this has not been done.
Adding insult to the injury is the
fact that not only the Office of Chief Commissioner for Persons with Disabilities
not been strengthened but in fact the statutory recognition that was given
to Central and State Coordination and Executive Committees has also been withdrawn.
“The implementation and monitoring of the PWD Act
has been the weakest link. We need an Act that works and redresses the issues
faced by persons with disabilities. The Commissioner’s office appears more
helpless than the persons with the grievance. We need to strengthen the enforcing
mechanisms. However the proposed amendment posted on the official website
of the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment gives us an impression that
they intend to dilute the composition of the Central and State Executive and
Coordination Committees. “The composition of these Committees will now be
under the rules of the Act and in effect these powers will be in the hands
of the administrative authorities,” says C. Mahesh of Mobility India,
Presently, the PWD Act focuses mainly on the Socio-Economic rights. The proposed amendments have really not addressed the Civil and Political rights which include – right to life, right to political participation, right to marriage, home and family, legal capacity, access to justice, freedom of movement, right to privacy – some of the articles that have already been included in the Draft U.N. Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities.
Amita Dhandha Committee’s recommendations complied with the rights-based approach and addressed the concerns of all vulnerable groups like women with disabilities, children and persons with severe disabilities, destitute persons with disability, aged persons without carers, parents, etc. The concerns included social security, health, education, insurance, employment and accessibility.
The amendments proposed by M.S.J.E. address some of these concerns in a very superficial manner. Most of these concerns/issues have not been addressed at all. There is nothing for persons with severe disability, or women with disabilities, destitute and aged persons with disabilities. Some of the changes proposed by M.S.J.E. include:
1. Preparing a comprehensive and inclusive education scheme compatible with the special needs of students with disabilities by providing additional support and provisions in regular schools and institutions of higher and technical education, and also projects in the field of education and training in formal, non-formal, vocational, open learning system and other such sectors.
2. Carrying forward the vacancy to five years and in case suitable person belonging to the said class of disability is not available interchanging them among the classes of persons with disabilities who are entitled for reservation.
3. Vocational Rehabilitation Centres have been assigned the additional task of acting as Employment Exchanges.
4. The provision of amanuensis or any other alternative systems of taking examinations has been proposed for all such persons with disabilities who are unable to write the examination by themselves.
The change which was most desired by the disability sector
was that more teeth be given to the Office of Chief Commissioner for Persons
with Disabilities. Its rulings be made enforceable
and non-violable and they be strengthened with some penalising
powers. However, the only change that has been proposed is that this office
should coordinate the work of Central Government
Departments and agencies responsible for the implementation of the Act and
receive reports from each of them at such intervals and in such form as may
be prescribed. Coordinate with the States/
Thus, these proposed amendments
are nothing but a mere eye-wash. If the Ministry succeeds in going ahead with
these amendments, disability sector will not get another opportunity to correct
the wrongs of the present Act for a very long time to come. Unless, disability
sector exercises substantial pressure to get the desired changes that have been
envisioned in the Biwako Millennium Framework and in
the Draft UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with
Disabilities which would soon be ratified, the disabled people in
DNIS is produced and managed by:
National Centre for Promotion of Employment for Disabled People
Rights of Persons with Disabilities Bill
Mental Health Care Bill
CRPD Monitoring Report
- List of Awardees 2014 :NCPEDP MPHASIS Universal Design Awards (1 MB)
- List of Awardees 2013 :NCPEDP MPHASIS Universal Design Awards (1.44 MB)
- List of Awardees 2012 :NCPEDP MPHASIS Universal Design Awards (804 KB)
- List of Awardees 2011 :NCPEDP MPHASIS Universal Design Awards (864 KB)
- List of Awardees 2010 :NCPEDP MPHASIS Universal Design Awards (623 KB)
SHELL HELEN KELLER AWARDS
NCPEDP-Shell Helen Keller Awardees 2013
- Sign Language - the Life Line for Deaf People
- M.S.J.E.’s Proposed Amendments to the Disability Act – a façade for Inclusion, Justice & Empowerment
- M.S.J.E. backtracks! Amendments to the Disability Act postponed
- Elections for the Board of the National Trust announced
- Railways to add reserved wheelchair compartments to all mail express trains
- Bombay H.C. directs schools to abide by guidelines for dyslexic students
- Karnataka H.C. dismisses plea of disabled girl for seat in professional course
- Allocate funds for mental health: Child rights activists and child mental health specialists
- Governor intervenes; Disabled boy readmitted in school
- Centre directs its departments to fill up vacancies for disabled people
- D.U. to implement three per cent reservation for disabled teachers, students
- Revolutionary technology for people with brain and spinal injuries
Disability News and Information Service is produced and managed by: